At least it’s not my situation where Belle Tire put new tires on my ex wife’s mini van (we were married back then). After not 2 weeks the belting came off to the point all the steel wires were showing. Belle tried to tell me it was because my alignment was off by -.1 on that tire. I raised hell and got them to replace all 4 because I ended up going above the store managers head. But in this case you def have a leg to stand on. BTW I was 22 (18 years ago) and I havent been back to Belle except to use the free air since then. I was still young and clearly didnt know as much as I do now.